On this page9 sections
Key takeaways
- Only 19.3% of US job postings required a bachelor's degree or more as of November 2025, while 51% listed no education requirement at all (Indeed Hiring Lab, Jan 2026).
- Fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023 actually benefited from an employer dropping a degree requirement (Harvard Business School/Burning Glass Institute, Feb 2024).
- 85% of employers say they use skills-based hiring, and 53% have dropped degree requirements (TestGorilla survey, April 2025).
- 68% of US hiring decision-makers still prefer a candidate with at least a bachelor's degree, even for jobs that don't require one (Lumina-Gallup, Oct 2026).
- More than 75 million US workers are STARs (skilled through alternative routes) and skills-first practices could open 1.5M+ public-sector jobs for them by 2030 (Opportunity@Work, June 2026).
Yes and no, and the gap between the two is where job seekers get hurt. Degree requirements have fallen to their lowest levels in years: only 19.3% of US job postings required a bachelor’s degree or more as of November 2025, and 51% listed no education requirement at all, according to Indeed Hiring Lab. But what employers actually hire for is changing far more slowly than what their job ads say, and since 2024 the requirements have quietly started creeping back.
So the paperwork has changed faster than the practice. What follows separates the measured trends from the marketing, with dates and sources on every number. It also shows exactly where the door is open if you don’t have a degree, and where it’s still shut.
What the Job-Posting Data Actually Says About Degree Requirements
Degree requirements on job postings have fallen sharply since 2019, but they stopped falling in 2024 and have started to reverse. That second half is the part most trend pieces leave out.
Indeed Hiring Lab’s January 2026 analysis found that 19.3% of US postings required a bachelor’s degree or higher in November 2025, up from 16.6% in November 2023, though still slightly below pre-pandemic levels. Meanwhile, 51% of postings listed no formal education requirement at all. So roughly half the market doesn’t mention a degree, about one in five postings demands one, and the rest sit somewhere in between with vague “preferred” language.
The creep back up gets more interesting when you control for what kinds of jobs are being posted. Adjusted for occupational mix, the degree-required share hit a five-year low of 18.5% in March 2024 and rose to 18.6% by November 2025, which means employers are raising education requirements within the same occupations, not just posting for different jobs. When the labor market was desperate in 2021–2023, requirements came down; as hiring cooled, some of that flexing went away.
There’s also a huge geographic spread. In raw terms, 43.7% of postings in Washington, D.C. required a bachelor’s or higher in November 2025, versus 11.3% in Mississippi. And some sectors barely moved at all. Where degree requirements still stick hardest, per Indeed’s analysis:
- Legal, finance, and professional services
- STEM research roles
- Federal government and policy work
- Licensed health occupations, where the law often makes the degree non-negotiable
What Employers Say vs. What They Actually Do
Employers overwhelmingly describe themselves as skills-first, but their screening habits and their hires tell a messier story. Surveys measure intentions; postings and payroll measure behavior.
On the intentions side, TestGorilla’s State of Skills-Based Hiring 2025 surveyed 1,084 employers and 1,076 job seekers in the US and UK in April 2025. It found 85% of employers say they use skills-based hiring, up from 81% in 2024 and 73% in 2023, and 53% say they’ve dropped degree requirements from at least some roles, up from 30% the year before, with US employers (57%) ahead of UK ones (50%). NACE’s Job Outlook 2026, published in January 2026 from employer surveys collected that August and September, put adoption at 70%, up from 65% the prior year. NACE also found GPA screening has collapsed: 73% of employers screened candidates by GPA in 2019, but only 42% do now.
Now the behavior side. In February 2024, Harvard Business School’s Project on Managing the Future of Work and the Burning Glass Institute published the study that cut through the cheerleading, Skills-Based Hiring: The Long Road from Pronouncements to Practice by Matt Sigelman, Joseph Fuller, and Alex Martin. As HR Dive reported when it came out:
Fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023 (roughly 97,000 workers out of 77 million annual hires) actually benefited from an employer dropping a degree requirement.
Read that twice. The single most-quoted achievement of the skills-first movement, dropping degree requirements, changed who got hired at a rate of less than 0.15% of the market. The study sorted big employers into three groups: 37% were “leaders” that followed through and raised their share of non-degreed workers by nearly 20%; 45% were “in name only” companies that announced changes and changed nothing; 18% were “backsliders” who briefly hired differently and then reverted. Notably, the report also found that when firms did hire workers without degrees into previously degree-requiring roles, those workers stayed about 10 percentage points longer, so the approach works when it’s actually practiced.
And there’s a third data point that rarely makes the highlight reels. Lumina Foundation’s October 2026 analysis of a Gallup survey of 2,500 US hiring decision-makers found that 68% prefer a candidate with at least a bachelor’s degree even for jobs that don’t require one. TestGorilla’s own survey backs the vibe: 41% of employers think degrees are more important than five years ago, versus 32% who say less important.
Here’s the side-by-side:
| What employers say (claim) | What postings and hires show (evidence) | Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| 85% use skills-based hiring (TestGorilla, Apr 2025) | Fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023 came from dropped degree requirements (Harvard/Burning Glass Institute, Feb 2024) | Directionally true, deeply uneven in practice |
| 53% have dropped degree requirements (TestGorilla, Apr 2025) | Degree-required postings rose from 16.6% to 19.3% between Nov 2023 and Nov 2025 (Indeed Hiring Lab, Jan 2026) | Paper change outpaced real change |
| 70% report skills-based hiring (NACE, Jan 2026) | 68% still prefer a degree-holder for jobs that don’t require one (Lumina-Gallup, Oct 2026) | The preference outlives the posting |
| “We hire for skills, not diplomas”, state government | 92% of Pennsylvania state jobs and ~90% of Virginia’s classified positions dropped the requirement (governor’s office, Jan 2023; NGA, June 2023) | The most concrete, verifiable win |
Why Employers Say One Thing and Hire Another
Because deleting a degree line from a posting is cheap, while rebuilding how you screen, interview, and promote is expensive and risky. Most companies did the first thing and called it a day.
Indeed’s own researchers flagged the tell: postings without formal education requirements still tend to hire degree holders anyway. Hiring managers use the degree as a fast proxy for reliability and communication skills, especially when they’re drowning in applications. Applicant tracking systems filter on keywords, and “bachelor’s degree” is an easy keyword to keep in the machine even after the careers page says skills-first.
There’s also plain market physics. When employers were short-staffed in 2021–2023, they widened the funnel; when applications per opening climbed back up, they quietly narrowed it again. That’s exactly what the adjusted numbers from Indeed show. None of this means the movement was fake; it means most of it was never operationalized.
What State Governments Have Actually Changed
State government is where degree requirements have genuinely been torn out, by executive order, at scale. If you don’t have a degree, public-sector job boards are the most concrete place this trend is real.
Pennsylvania’s governor’s office announced Executive Order 2023-03 on January 18, 2023, removing the four-year degree requirement from 92% of roughly 65,000 Commonwealth jobs. The National Governors Association counted ten states acting on this by mid-2023: Virginia eliminated degree requirements or preferences for nearly 90% of classified positions, North Carolina’s Executive Order 278 let experience substitute for degrees in about 75% of job classifications, and New Jersey, Maryland, Colorado, Alaska, South Dakota, and Ohio all moved too. Utah’s Department of Human Resource Management still runs skills-based hiring as a standing pathway today, and the state estimates 98% of its public-sector jobs don’t require a bachelor’s degree.
The worker-level stakes are enormous. STARs are workers Skilled Through Alternative Routes (community college, military service, apprenticeships, bootcamps, or on-the-job experience instead of a bachelor’s degree) and they make up more than 75 million US workers. Opportunity@Work’s State of the Paper Ceiling 2026 report, released in June 2026, found 37% of employers have changed degree requirements, and that STARs who moved into higher-paying jobs in 2024 gained a median of $14,800 in annual wages. The report estimates skills-first practices could open 1.5 million-plus public-sector jobs to STARs by 2030, with up to 10 million STARs moving to higher-wage work overall.
One warning from that report deserves more attention than it gets. Opportunity@Work argues that AI hiring tools will bake today’s design choices into tomorrow’s screening, and without deliberate skills-first design, “the paper ceiling won’t just persist; it will be automated.” In other words, the window can close again.
Where the Door Is Open Without a Degree, and Where It’s Still Closed
The door is widest in state and local government, the skilled trades, sales, and pockets of tech. It remains largely shut in licensed professions, academia, and degree-heavy sectors like legal, finance, and federal policy work.
Where the evidence says you can realistically compete without a four-year degree:
- State and local government. Pennsylvania, Virginia, North Carolina, Utah, and half a dozen other states have structurally removed the requirement, and Opportunity@Work projects the public sector is where skills-first hiring will open the most jobs by 2030.
- The skilled trades. Apprenticeships and licenses (not diplomas) are the currency here, and the work can’t be outsourced or easily automated.
- Tech support and entry-level cybersecurity. BLS’s Occupational Outlook Handbook (updated August 2026) projects 21% employment growth for information security analysts from 2025 to 2035, with a median wage of $129,180 as of May 2025. The catch: BLS still lists the typical entry education as a bachelor’s degree, so certifications plus demonstrable skills are the practical workaround, not a guaranteed bypass.
- Sales. Results are the only credential that matters, and commission structures give you a shot regardless of your transcript.
Where the degree requirement is still firmly in place:
- Licensed professions (medicine, nursing, law, engineering) where the degree is a legal prerequisite, not a preference.
- Academia and research, where the credential is the job.
- Legal, finance, professional services, and STEM-heavy corporate work, which Indeed’s posting data shows still screen hardest for degrees.
And here’s the part that doesn’t get sugarcoated: dropping the requirement from a posting doesn’t erase the wage premium for people who have the degree. BLS data from the second quarter of 2025 shows full-time workers 25 and older with only a bachelor’s degree earned a median of $1,559 per week, versus $960 for high school graduates with no college and $1,912 for those with advanced degrees. BLS’s Education Pays chart shows the same pattern on unemployment: 2.5% for bachelor’s holders in 2024 versus 4.2% for high school grads. Even recent graduates aren’t escaping scrutiny; Lumina cites New York Fed data showing about 5.6% of recent grads were unemployed in Q2 2026, with 42% underemployed. The degree still pays, on average. Skills-first hiring just means it’s no longer the only way in.
What to Do If You’re Job Hunting Without a Degree
Treat skills-first hiring as an opening, not a guarantee, and aim your applications where the evidence says practice has caught up with promises. Half the postings out there list no education requirement, and plenty of others say a degree is “preferred”, which is negotiable language, not a gate.
If a role drops its degree requirement:
- Don’t self-reject. With 51% of postings listing no requirement and many others listing “preferred,” apply if you can do the work. The degree filter is weaker than it looks, but only for people who actually apply.
- Lead with proof, not promises. Certifications, portfolios, and measurable results are how you substitute for the credential. If you want to know how employers weigh those signals, see our guide on whether skills tests matter more than resumes.
- Translate your experience into the posting’s language. Side projects, freelance work, and volunteer work count as experience when you frame them properly, our breakdown of what counts as relevant experience shows how.
- Ignore the fake experience bars. Plenty of “entry-level” postings asking for three years of experience are negotiating positions, not requirements. We cover how to handle that in entry-level jobs asking for three years of experience.
- Check public-sector boards first. That’s where requirements were removed by policy, not just by press release.
The Verdict
The skills-first movement is real, half-finished, and slightly in reverse. Job postings genuinely shed degree requirements between 2019 and 2024 (that part is measured, not marketing) but hiring practice lagged badly, fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023 reflected the change, and the posting data has been creeping back up since early 2024.
The durable wins are in government, the trades, and companies that rebuilt their assessments rather than just editing their postings. The degree premium in wages isn’t going anywhere soon, and 48% of hiring decision-makers told Lumina-Gallup they expect AI to make degrees more important over the next five years; a reminder that this trend can run backwards. So: if you have the degree, it still helps. If you don’t, you have more genuine openings than at any point since 2019, especially in public-sector and skills-tested roles. Just aim them where the evidence says the door is actually open.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does skills-based hiring mean? Skills-based hiring means evaluating candidates on demonstrated abilities, work samples, and assessments rather than formal credentials like a bachelor’s degree. In practice it shows up as skills tests, structured interviews, and experience-based screening. Adoption is broad on paper: 70% of employers told NACE they use it (January 2026), and 85% said so in TestGorilla’s April 2025 survey.
What percentage of jobs require a college degree in 2026? Only 19.3% of US job postings required a bachelor’s degree or higher as of November 2025, the latest figure in Indeed Hiring Lab’s January 2026 analysis. Another 51% of postings listed no formal education requirement at all.
Do employers actually hire people without degrees after dropping the requirement? Mostly no, at least historically. A February 2024 Harvard Business School/Burning Glass Institute study found fewer than 1 in 700 hires in 2023 benefited from dropped degree requirements, though the 37% of companies it labeled “leaders” did meaningfully shift who they hired.
Which states dropped degree requirements for state jobs? Pennsylvania removed the requirement from 92% of roughly 65,000 state jobs in January 2023, and Virginia dropped it for nearly 90% of classified positions. North Carolina, Utah, New Jersey, Maryland, Colorado, Alaska, South Dakota, and Ohio also acted, per the National Governors Association.
Can you get a tech job without a degree? Yes in IT support, helpdesk, and entry-level cybersecurity paths, where certifications like Security+ and a portfolio of work are the standard substitutes. Know the fine print, though: BLS lists the typical entry education for information security analysts as a bachelor’s degree, even as it projects 21% job growth for the field through 2035.
Do college graduates still earn more than workers without degrees? Yes, substantially. BLS data for Q2 2025 shows median weekly earnings of $1,559 for bachelor’s-only workers 25 and older versus $960 for high school graduates, and 2024 unemployment rates of 2.5% versus 4.2%.
Will AI make degrees more or less important? Hiring decision-makers lean toward “more”: 48% expect AI to make degrees more important over the next five years, per Lumina-Gallup’s October 2026 survey. Opportunity@Work offers the counter-warning; that AI could just as easily automate old degree screens into new tools unless employers deliberately design skills-first processes.
Is skills-based hiring just a fad? No, but it’s a slower rewiring than the headlines implied. The posting-level change is real and mostly durable, while hiring-practice change is uneven and partially reversible. Trust it where it’s backed by policy or assessments (state government, the trades, skills-tested employers), and stay skeptical where it’s backed only by a careers-page slogan.
Sources
- Indeed Hiring Lab: Where Do College Degrees Still Matter in a “Skills-First” Job Market? (Jan 28, 2026)
- Burning Glass Institute / Harvard Business School: Skills-Based Hiring: The Long Road from Pronouncements to Practice (Feb 2024)
- HR Dive: Report: Employers don’t practice what they preach on skills-based hiring (Feb 20, 2024)
- TestGorilla: The State of Skills-Based Hiring 2025 (survey conducted April 2025)
- NACE: Employer Use of Skills-Based Hiring Practices Grows (Job Outlook 2026, published Jan 12, 2026)
- Lumina Foundation: Employers still want the degree (Oct 20, 2026)
- BLS: Usual Weekly Earnings of Wage and Salary Workers, Second Quarter 2025 (released Jul 22, 2025)
- BLS Career Outlook: Education Pays, 2024 (published May 2025)
- BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook: Information Security Analysts (updated Aug 27, 2026)
- Opportunity@Work: State of the Paper Ceiling 2026 (June 2026)
- Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Governor Shapiro Signs First Executive Order, Announcing 92 Percent of Commonwealth Jobs Do Not Require a Four-Year Degree (Jan 18, 2023)
- Utah Department of Human Resource Management: Skills-Based Hiring Pathways
- National Governors Association: Governors Leading on Skills-Based Hiring to Open Opportunity Pathways (June 1, 2023)
Written by ResumeFlex. Questions or corrections? Contact ResumeFlex. Read our source and correction standards.
Filed under
Job Search