On this page8 sections
Key takeaways
- A median role now takes 62 days to fill and draws 194 applications per hire, per Greenhouse recruiting benchmarks (data through August 2026).
- Greenhouse platform data shows 18–22% of postings in any given quarter show no hiring activity, the 'ghost job' band (December 2024 report).
- One in three openings on Greenhouse's platform closes with no hire at all (2026 benchmarks).
- LinkedIn keeps free job posts live until closed or for 6 months; Indeed cuts free visibility off at 30 days (both platforms' help docs).
- Recruiter reply rates on fresh requisitions run about 1.34x those on postings aged 90+ days (Pin, November 2026).
Companies keep job openings online for months for three different reasons: the role is an evergreen pipeline posting that’s meant to stay open, the hire is real but stuck in a slow process, or the listing is a ghost job nobody plans to fill. Only that last category is deceptive, and it’s a minority, roughly one in five postings by Greenhouse’s own count. Most months-old listings are churn, compliance, or plain inertia.
The data is worth taking seriously either way. Greenhouse’s recruiting benchmarks, built on platform data through August 2026, put the median time to fill a role at 62 days, with 194 applications per hire, and one in three openings closes with no hire at all (Greenhouse Recruiting Benchmarks). The federal count points the same direction: 7.5 million job openings against only 5.4 million hires in September 2026 (BLS, November 2026).
So the short answer to “why is this posting still up?” is usually: something behind it is stuck, ongoing, or abandoned. The useful skill is figuring out which of those three things you’re looking at.
Evergreen, Ghost, or Slow Hire? Three Things People Keep Conflating
A long-running posting may be an active vacancy, an ongoing talent search, or an inactive listing. Check which one it appears to be before spending time on a tailored application.
An evergreen requisition is a job a company deliberately keeps posted year-round. Textio, a hiring-language company, defines it as “a position at your organization that is always open” (Textio, June 2018). High-turnover roles (sales reps, customer service, nurses, drivers) fit the model: the door stays open because another vacancy is always coming.
A slow hire is a real, current vacancy that’s taking too long to fill. Nothing is fake here. The requisition sat waiting for budget sign-off, the hiring manager wanted a stronger slate, or the pay is below what the market will bear.
A ghost job is a posting the company has no real intent to fill, or one left up after the role was filled. Greenhouse’s platform data puts this at 18–22% of postings in any given quarter (Greenhouse, December 2024), real, but far from most of what you see.
| Evergreen req | Slow hire | Ghost job | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Deliberately always-open posting, often for high-turnover roles | Real vacancy stuck in a slow or stalled process | No intent to fill, or filled and simply never taken down |
| Tell-tale signals | Same title up continuously for 6+ months; “continuous” or “evergreen” wording; careers page that’s always hiring | Posted once, not endlessly reposted; specific requirements; recruiter still answers messages | No human reply after the auto-confirmation; identical listing synced across many boards; vague or inflated requirements |
| What to do | Apply, but expect a queue rather than a quick screen | Apply, then follow up with the recruiter or hiring manager directly | Apply only if it costs you minutes; don’t build your week around it |
The middle column is the one job seekers misjudge most. The common assumption is “still up after 60 days” means “fake,” when “slow” is at least as common.
Why Companies Leave Job Openings Up: Six Reasons That Cover Almost Everything
Six reasons explain nearly every months-old posting: pipeline building, compliance, stalled approvals, hard-to-fill or underpaid roles, branding, and neglect. Ranking them by how much they actually explain, here’s what’s going on.
- Pipeline building for high-turnover roles. Some jobs get hired so often that closing and reposting the ad every few weeks would be pointless. The company wants a standing pool of applicants it can dip into the next time someone quits, which is why evergreen reqs cluster in sales, support, and hourly work (Textio, 2018).
- Compliance and policy posting. There’s no federal rule forcing private employers to advertise openings on their own career sites, but federal contractors with contracts of $150,000 or more must list openings with their state job bank and keep those listings active until the role is filled (Circa). Many big employers also post externally to document a fair internal-vs-external search, even when an internal candidate is the front-runner.
- Approvals and budget stalls. A req can be live while the money behind it is still being re-approved, frozen, or re-scoped after a leadership change. SHRM’s 2026 benchmarking found over 2 in 3 organizations struggled to hire for open positions (SHRM, 2026), and freeze-then-revive cycles leave postings dangling in between.
- The role is hard to fill, or pays below market. The listing stays up because the company genuinely hasn’t found anyone willing to take the job at the offered terms. That’s not a trick, but it is information about how the negotiation will go later.
- Optics. In a May 2024 Resume Builder survey of 649 hiring managers, 4 in 10 companies said they’d posted a fake listing that year, and 3 in 10 said they were currently advertising a role that wasn’t real; with “appearing to be growing” among the stated motives (CNBC, June 2024).
- Nobody takes it down. Platform defaults do half the work here. A free LinkedIn post stays live until someone manually closes it, or it auto-closes after six months (LinkedIn Help). Removing a dead req requires someone to log into the ATS and care, and in a stretched recruiting team, that someone doesn’t exist.
That last bullet deserves a bit of pushback against the internet’s favorite theory. Job seekers love to assume every stale listing is a deliberate deception. Half the time it’s the opposite: an honest vacancy nobody has spare cycles to clean up.
What the Data Actually Shows About Stale Listings
The evidence says hiring really is slower and more backlogged than it was before 2020, and a meaningful minority of listings never lead to a hire. But it also says most listings still do.
- The openings-to-hires gap has roughly tripled. Before 2020, monthly job openings exceeded hires by less than 10%; the gap hit 38% in 2021 and has held around 28–32% since, in June 2025, employers reported 7.4 million openings but made only 5.2 million hires (HR Dive, November 2025).
- The gap is worst in exactly the sectors that post the most. That analysis put the openings-vs-hires gap at 60% in government, 50% in education and health, and 48% in information, while construction and hospitality came closest to balance (HR Dive, 2025).
- Time-to-fill numbers vary by method, not by reality. Greenhouse reports a median of 62 days to fill a role in its 2026 benchmarks (Greenhouse); SHRM’s separate survey of 4,600+ organizations found a median of 39 calendar days for nonexecutive roles (SHRM, 2026). Different samples, different definitions, but both mean a posting is normal for weeks, not days.
- The “ghost” band has held steady at 18–22% of postings per quarter in Greenhouse’s platform data (Greenhouse, December 2024), and 69% of US job seekers told Greenhouse they’d personally run into fake postings (Greenhouse, November 2025).
- Matching postings to actual hires is getting harder across the board. Revelio Labs tracked steep drops in hires-per-posting from 2018 to 2022, down 55.2% in administrative and support services and 54.9% in construction (Revelio Labs, October 2023).
Here’s the single stat that belongs on every job board:
Of every 1,000 applications Greenhouse tracked through August 2026, only 32 ever reached a first interview, and just 5 ended in a hire. (Greenhouse Recruiting Benchmarks)
Read that alongside the 194 applications per hire figure and the picture sharpens: the odds were never about how fast you clicked “apply.” Still, one of 194 competing for a real hire beats one of 12 feeding a resume database.
How to Read the Age Signals on a Listing
Posting age is a real but noisy signal, under two weeks you’re early, past 60 days the odds drop, and past 90 days assume evergreen, stalled, or dead until a human tells you otherwise. The platform you’re searching on changes what age even means.
LinkedIn keeps free posts up until a recruiter closes them, with a six-month auto-close (LinkedIn Help), and a repost is counted as a brand-new post with a fresh date. Indeed is different: free postings stay visible for only 30 days, so anything older has either been sponsored (paid promotion that keeps it in search results) or deliberately re-posted (Indeed Help). Sponsored jobs also show up far more often, with Indeed citing 3.1x the impressions per day (Indeed, Hire resources).
- 0–14 days: Best window. Screening happens on a rolling basis, and recruiter attention is highest. If you see a role at day two, this is your moment.
- 15–30 days: Still normal. Most processes from the benchmarks run well past a month (Greenhouse), so the posting being up is expected.
- 31–60 days: Hmm territory. Apply if the fit is strong, but start checking for signs of life, recruiter activity, updated dates, movement in the listing.
- 60–90+ days: Assume evergreen or stalled unless you see evidence otherwise. Reply rates on outreach tied to 90+ day requisitions are measurably lower (Pin, November 2026).
- Reposted repeatedly: A role closed and reopened several times can mean a renewed search, or churn, an unstable budget, or a role nobody wants. It’s a question to ask in an interview, not a reason to skip.
Because fresher is genuinely better, the highest-impact fix on your side is catching postings early; setting tighter alerts is the easiest upgrade, and our guide to better LinkedIn job alerts without the noise walks through it.
Are Months-Old Openings Worth Applying To?
Yes, apply if you’re a strong match, but treat anything past 30 days as a longer shot and don’t reorganize your search around it. Aged does not mean fake: if 18–22% of postings show no hiring activity, that leaves roughly four in five that do (Greenhouse, 2024).
The best recent numbers on this come from Pin, which analyzed 1.9 million recruiter outreach sequences created between October 2025 and August 2026. Recruiter reply rates on requisitions under 30 days old hit 11.31%, dropped to 9.54% at 30–90 days, and 8.43% at 90-plus, so fresh requisitions earned about 1.34x the replies of stale ones (Pin, November 2026). Crucially, the same companies showed the same pattern, so it’s not just that “easy-to-fill companies” post fresh roles. Pin’s own data also shows candidates’ “is this role still open?” questions tripled between late 2024 and late 2025, you’re not imagining the confusion.
Older postings had lower reply rates in this dataset, but that does not prove that age itself caused the difference. An opening may have been paused or nearly filled. Use its age as one reason to check whether hiring is still active.
Here’s the decision flow for any posting older than a month:
- Date it. Is this the original posting or a repost? On LinkedIn, check when it was first published versus whether the company has closed-and-reposted it.
- Check the platform. On Indeed, 30 days or older means someone is paying to keep it visible; sponsorship is a decent proxy for an active search (Indeed Help).
- Look for signs of life. Application status stuck on “received” tells you little; a move to a later stage tells you a lot. If yours says otherwise, our explainer on what “under review” means on a job application covers what each status actually signals.
- Run a fit check. If you meet most of the core requirements, apply regardless of age. At 194 applications per hire, marginal candidates lose on volume, not on timing.
- Weigh effort against odds. A two-minute easy apply at day 75 costs you nothing. A 45-minute screener for a 90-day-old posting is a bad trade unless the fit is exceptional.
- Go around the queue. Message the recruiter or hiring manager directly and ask whether the role is still active. It’s the single cheapest way to convert a stale listing into real information.
If you want a deeper checklist on separating real listings from hollow ones, our guide to ghost jobs picks up where this one ends.
If You’re the Company: What This Is Costing You
Stale postings cost employers trust and candidate quality, and the fixes are mostly discipline, not budget. Close or relabel anything you wouldn’t hire from this quarter.
The cleanest rule comes from Textio: one requisition ID should equal one hire and one job description, so your hiring data, and your candidates’ experience; stays honest (Textio, 2018). Label genuine evergreen reqs as continuous recruitment so applicants know what they’re entering. And close postings within two weeks of filling; that’s exactly what New Jersey’s pending ghost-jobs bill would require, and whether or not it passes, it’s a fair preview of where regulation is heading. The trust tax is already real: 69% of US job seekers say they’ve encountered fake postings (Greenhouse, November 2025), and a candidate who assumes every listing is a lie won’t bother applying to your real ones.
FAQ
Why do companies post jobs they have no intention of filling? Mostly to build a resume pipeline and look like they’re growing faster than they are. In a May 2024 survey of 649 hiring managers, 4 in 10 companies admitted posting a fake listing that year (CNBC).
Are companies legally required to keep job postings online? Generally no. Private employers face no federal requirement to advertise openings on their own career sites, though federal contractors with contracts of $150,000 or more must list openings with their state job bank until filled (Circa).
What percentage of job postings are ghost jobs? Greenhouse’s platform data shows 18–22% of postings in any given quarter have no hiring activity (Greenhouse, December 2024). Estimates vary with definitions, but roughly one in five is a defensible planning number.
Is it worth applying to a job posted two months ago? Usually yes, if you’re a strong match. Reply rates are lower on older requisitions, about 1.34x worse for 90-day-old roles than fresh ones (Pin, November 2026), but aged listings still lead to hires, and a direct follow-up message improves your information odds.
How long do job postings stay active on LinkedIn and Indeed? On LinkedIn, a free post stays live until closed manually or for six months, whichever comes first (LinkedIn Help). On Indeed, free postings stay visible up to 30 days, and only sponsorship keeps them searchable afterward (Indeed Help).
What does it mean when a company reposts the same job? It can mean the first search failed, the budget was renewed, or the recruiter is refreshing the listing for visibility in search results. One repost is usually benign; the same role appearing every few weeks for a year is a question worth asking.
Do companies leave postings up after the position is filled? Some do, sometimes for weeks. That’s part of why 3 in 10 companies in the Resume Builder survey said they were currently advertising a role that wasn’t real (CNBC, 2024), a filled-but-unclosed listing and a deliberately fake one look identical from outside.
Should I mention in my application that the posting looks old? No. Age comments read as skepticism and don’t help you screen in. Apply clean, then ask the recruiter directly whether the role is still active; that gets you the same answer with better manners.
Sources
- BLS: Job Openings and Labor Turnover Summary, September 2026 (released November 3, 2026)
- CNBC: “4 in 10 companies say they’ve posted a fake job this year” (June 27, 2024)
- Circa (CircaWorks): “Minimum external job posting requirement” expert Q&A
- Greenhouse: Recruiting Benchmarks (platform data through August 2026)
- Greenhouse: 2024 State of Job Hunting Report (published December 10, 2024)
- Greenhouse Newsroom: 2025 AI in Hiring Report (published November 19, 2025)
- HR Dive: “1 in 3 US job listings go nowhere, creating a ‘ghost job economy’” (November 14, 2025)
- Indeed Help Center: FAQs on the Free Job Post Policy
- Indeed (Hire resources): Free vs. Sponsored Jobs
- LinkedIn Help: Renewability and duration of a job posting
- Pin: “Ghost Jobs in 2026: How Stale Reqs Cost Recruiter Replies” (November 11, 2026)
- Revelio Labs: “Ghost Jobs: Ghost Job Postings Surging” (October 2023)
- SHRM: 2026 Recruiting Executives Benchmarking
- Textio: “Why evergreen roles screw up your hiring data” (June 15, 2018)
Written by ResumeFlex. Questions or corrections? Contact ResumeFlex. Read our source and correction standards.
Filed under
Job Search