On this page10 sections
Key takeaways
- Reported losses to job scams tripled from 2020 to 2023 and topped $220 million in the first half of 2024 (FTC, Dec 2024).
- Employment scams were the second-riskiest scam type in 2025, and BBB Scam Tracker reports roughly doubled year over year (BBB, 2025 Risk Report and 2026 update).
- An invalid equity valuation can leave option holders owing immediate taxes plus a 20% penalty (Carta, 2026).
- Unpaid 'trial periods' for real work are not legal: FLSA rights like minimum wage can't be waived (US Dept. of Labor).
- A complete offer letter lists title, pay, bonus and equity terms, start date, benefits, contingencies, and at-will status (SHRM).
Most job offer red flags come down to three things: missing specifics, manufactured urgency, and requests no legitimate employer would make. A real offer states the title, the pay, the start date, and the conditions attached, in writing, with a few days to review. If any of that is vague, absent, or rushed, you’ve found exactly what to fix before you sign.
Context for why this matters right now: reported losses to job scams tripled from 2020 to 2023 and topped $220 million in just the first six months of 2024, per FTC data, and task scams alone made up nearly 40% of job scam reports in 2024. The wave didn’t cool off in 2025 either. BBB Scam Tracker received more than 23,000 employment scam reports in 2025, roughly double the year before, which helped make employment scams the second-riskiest scam type in BBB’s 2025 Risk Report, behind only investment schemes.
None of this means treating every recruiter as a crook. It means the window between “we’d like to offer you the position” and your signature is a verification window, and it deserves a checklist.
Reported losses to job scams: tripled from 2020 to 2023, and over $220 million in just the first half of 2024 alone., FTC Data Spotlight, December 12, 2024
The red-flag table: severity first
Not all red flags deserve the same response; some mean fraud, some mean verify hard, and some mean negotiate. Use the severity column to decide whether the right move is to walk, to verify, or to counter.
| Severity | Red flag | What it looks like | Why it matters | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dealbreaker; likely fraud | You pay to start | “Training kit,” starter equipment, background-check fee, crypto deposit | The FTC is blunt: honest employers, including the federal government, never ask you to pay to get a job | Decline and report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov |
| Dealbreaker | Check to deposit and forward | A check arrives before day one; you’re told to wire back the “extra” | Classic fake-check scam; the check bounces and your bank claws back the full amount | Don’t deposit; report to the FTC |
| Dealbreaker | SSN, bank, or card details before a written offer | “Payroll setup” or screening fees during interviews | The FBI’s IC3 lists PII and account collection before hiring as a scam marker | Refuse; verify the company independently |
| Dealbreaker | Text- or WhatsApp-only “interview” | No secured video call, no company email, a job you never applied for | IC3 flags non-company domains and fast, one-person hires | Require a real video call via the official site |
| Serious (verify before signing | Verbal offer, no paperwork | “HR is slow, paperwork later”) for weeks | A verbal offer is non-binding; the written offer is the enforceable document | Ask for a written timeline; keep searching until signed |
| Serious | “Sign today” pressure | A 24-hour deadline, refusal to extend | Healthy employers give decision room; Glassdoor flags instant offers as a warning sign | Ask for 3–5 business days, with a specific reason |
| Serious | Bonus or equity “TBD” | “We’ll sort the numbers out later” | Bonus and equity terms belong in the letter; verbal TBDs are unenforceable | Get target, criteria, and payout timing in writing |
| Serious | Unpaid trial or probation work | “First two weeks unpaid to start” | FLSA rights like minimum wage can’t be waived; real work must be paid | Decline; legitimate employers use paid probation |
| Serious | 1099 role with employee-shaped control | Fixed schedule, company equipment, one “client” | Federal classification tests would likely call you an employee | Request W-2 classification in writing |
| Yellow; common, often negotiable | Vague title and duties | “Growth hacker,” duties “subject to change” with no scope | You can’t benchmark pay or judge fit without scope | Ask for role scope in the letter |
| Yellow | Missing clawback limits | Signing bonus repayable in full on any departure | Repayment is usually gross, not net | Negotiate pro-rata terms and a no-cause exception |
| Yellow | Turnover signals | Recent reviews say “high turnover,” “burnout”; the role keeps being reposted | Toxic-management mentions rose sharply in recent Glassdoor data | Run the LinkedIn tenure check below |
| Yellow | “We’re a family” framing | Boundary-blurring, passion-hours talk | Glassdoor ties it to blurred boundaries and unpaid overtime | Ask about workload and after-hours norms directly |
Three patterns worth noticing in that table. Every dealbreaker involves value or data flowing from you to them, which is why the FTC’s rule is so blunt: “Honest employers, including the federal government, will never ask you to pay to get a job.”
The serious group is mostly an enforceability problem. A verbal promise is non-binding, and Rollins College’s career guidance notes the written offer is the legally binding document, so anything you care about needs to be in the letter, not in the conversation.
The yellow flags are calibration, not condemnation. Plenty of good companies flunk a couple of these, which makes them negotiating positions rather than exit triggers.
Scam-shaped offers vs. legit-but-ugly ones
The fastest calibration test: scams transfer something from you (money, identity data, or hours of unpaid “task” work) while ugly-but-real offers just underdeliver on information and pay. Judge by direction, not polish.
The 2025 BBB data shows how industrialized the fraud side has become. Employment scam reports to Scam Tracker “exploded in 2025, doubling over the previous year,” and about half of those reports listed text messages as the delivery method. Task scams, where you “earn” fake commissions for liking videos or rating products in an app, then get asked to deposit your own crypto to release the earnings, generated roughly 680 BBB reports in 2025 with a median loss of $2,300.
The FTC’s task-scam advice is worth memorizing because it’s short: never pay anyone to get paid, and ignore unexpected texts about “product boosting” or “optimization tasks,” since real employers don’t recruit that way.
Legit-but-ugly offers look different. HR is slow, the salary is 10% under market, the title is inflated, annoying, fixable, and common. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center markers, summarized by Delta Community Credit Union in February 2026, read almost opposite: interviews that never happen on a secured video call, contacts from non-company email domains, demands for hundreds or thousands of your own dollars for “equipment” with vague reimbursement promises, fees for a supposedly mandatory background check, and postings that appear on job boards but not on the company’s own site.
One more calibration point: the salary number itself. A too-good-to-be-true paycheck for easy work is a scam flag on BBB’s list, but a modest salary with complete written terms is just a negotiation.
How to verify the company in about 30 minutes
Four free checks catch most fake employers: the state business registry, the recruiter’s email domain, employee-review patterns, and the company’s public footprint. Do them in this order.
- State registry lookup. Search the company’s legal name in the Secretary of State business database for the state where it claims to be headquartered. You want “Active” or “Good Standing” status, a formation date consistent with the company’s story, and a registered agent that matches. No record, “Dissolved,” or a three-month-old entity claiming a decade of history means stop.
- Email domain. The recruiter’s address should match the company’s official domain. Lookalike domains (added hyphens, swapped letters, a .co where you expect .com) and free accounts like Gmail are exactly what the FBI’s IC3 warnings flag in fake-hiring schemes.
- Review patterns, recent ones. Read the last 6–12 months of Glassdoor and Indeed reviews, not the highlight reel at the top. Glassdoor’s own guidance says scan for the words “high turnover,” “burnout,” and “understaffed,” and to treat clusters of five-star reviews posted the same week with suspicion.
- Tenure math on LinkedIn. Check the median tenure stat on the company’s About tab, then scan the People tab for your specific role: how long did the last two or three incumbents stay? A role reposted every few months is churn made visible.
- Public footprint and press. Funding announcements, a functioning product, real employees commenting in public. Then the FTC’s favorite move: search the company name plus “scam,” “review,” and “complaint” before you accept.
The review data is worth taking seriously, because it’s gotten louder. Glassdoor Economic Research (May 2026), analyzing 9.6 million reviews, found reviewers were 6.7x more likely to mention a toxic boss in 2025 than in 2018, and 5.7x more likely to say it after leaving than while still employed. Read the ex-employee reviews first; that’s where the candor lives.
The offer-letter completeness checklist
A complete offer letter puts every promise in writing: who you work for, what you’re paid, what your equity is worth on paper, when you start, and what can cancel the deal. SHRM’s offer-letter guidance runs 14 elements (June 2017); here’s the candidate-side version, and every line should be filled in before you sign.
- Legal employer name: the actual entity paying you, not just the brand.
- Job title: specific, and matching what was discussed.
- Reporting line: your manager’s name and role.
- Classification: full-time or part-time, exempt or nonexempt (this controls overtime eligibility).
- Base pay: amount, pay frequency, and how the rate is quoted.
- Bonus or commission terms: target percentage, criteria, payout timing, guaranteed or discretionary.
- Equity terms: share count or percentage, strike price, vesting schedule, and what happens to vested shares if you leave.
- Benefits and PTO: plan summary, accrual rate, waiting periods.
- Start date, schedule, and location: including remote or hybrid terms if that was part of the deal.
- Contingencies: background check, drug screen, references, proof of right to work. Ask what’s actually verified; here’s what employers may verify in a background check.
- At-will language: more on that below.
- Signature lines and your response deadline: dated, and reasonable.
Anything promised verbally that isn’t on this list doesn’t exist yet. Get it added or get comfortable losing it.
One structural check too: know what you’re actually signing. The difference between an offer letter and an employment contract matters for what you can and can’t walk away from.
What at-will language means when you accept
At-will employment means either side can end the employment relationship at any time, for any lawful reason. Acceptance doesn’t lock you in, and it doesn’t lock them in either.
Under US law, employment is presumed at-will in 49 states; Montana is the exception, generally requiring employers to show good cause before dismissing an employee who has completed a probationary period, per Cornell Law School’s Wex legal dictionary (reviewed May 2021). The lawful-reason limits still apply, no firing for discriminatory or retaliatory reasons.
For you, the practical takeaway cuts both ways. Contingencies in the letter let the employer withdraw the offer before day one, so don’t resign your current job until contingencies clear. And once you’re in, the same doctrine that lets them end things also lets you leave whenever you choose.
The 1099 trap: contractor-shaped job offers
If a “contractor” role runs on a fixed schedule, company equipment, and a single client, the federal tests would likely classify you as an employee, whatever the paperwork says. The label is not the decision; the relationship is.
The Department of Labor’s FLSA analysis (the 2024 rule, effective March 11, 2024) weighs six “economic reality” factors: opportunity for profit or loss, investments by worker and employer, permanence of the relationship, degree of control, how integral the work is to the business, and skill and initiative, with no single factor decisive, per the DOL’s rule FAQs. Note the analysis is in flux: on February 26, 2026, DOL proposed replacing that rule, with the comment period closing April 28, 2026.
The IRS runs a separate common-law test for tax purposes with three categories: behavioral control, financial control, and the relationship of the parties, per IRS Topic 762 (reviewed September 2026). Set schedules, required training, company tools, and employee-style benefits all point toward employee.
The stakes are real. Misclassified workers can be denied minimum wage, overtime, and other protections employees get, per the DOL’s misclassification guidance. As a 1099 contractor you also cover both halves of payroll tax and typically get no benefits.
So ask directly: why is this role 1099? A genuine contractor engagement looks like a business, your own clients, your own tools, negotiated rates, no fixed schedule. If it looks like a normal job with a W-2-shaped hole, request employee classification in writing or keep looking.
Fix it now: your leverage disappears at signature
Almost every term is negotiable before you sign, and almost none are afterward. The offer stage is the highest-impact moment of the whole employment relationship, so treat it that way.
Most movable, based on what candidates report: base pay, signing bonus, start date, PTO, and remote or hybrid days. Also fixable now but much harder later: bonus criteria in writing, equity terms (count, strike price, vesting), clawback limits, and the title itself. Effectively fixed once signed: your tax classification, at-will status, and the design of the benefits plans.
Refusals at this stage are diagnostic too. Glassdoor flags employers who won’t negotiate pay or give inconsistent answers about it, and a company that stonewalls a reasonable written request before you’re hired is showing you the process for every future request.
To weigh all of this as one system rather than four disconnected numbers, work from a full base-pay-bonuses-equity-benefits breakdown; the total package is the real number.
When to walk away from a job offer
Walk away when value flows from you to them, when written answers keep being refused, or when your verification contradicts the pitch. Those three failures don’t fix themselves after a start date.
My specific lines in the sand:
- Any upfront payment, equipment purchase, deposit-and-forward check, or crypto transfer, at any stage.
- Refusal to put agreed compensation in the written offer.
- An employee-shaped 1099 arrangement that stays 1099 after you raise it.
- Failed verification: no state registration, mismatched domains, no real public footprint.
- Pressure that continues after you’ve asked, once and politely, for a few days.
Where the standard advice needs pushback: a lowball offer with complete terms is a negotiation, not a red flag. The more dangerous profile is the great salary with missing terms; the missing terms are where you get hurt.
Job offer FAQ
Should I ever accept a job offer without a written offer letter? No, a verbal offer is non-binding, so keep interviewing and searching until you have a written, signed offer in hand.
How much time should I ask for before deciding? Most employers will grant a few business days; ask early, affirm your interest, and give a specific reason and a specific date rather than an open-ended “I need more time.”
Are unpaid trial periods legal in the US? Not for real work, if you’re performing tasks that benefit the employer, you’re generally an employee entitled to at least minimum wage, and the DOL notes FLSA rights such as minimum wage and overtime can’t be waived.
What if the bonus or equity terms are “TBD”? Treat “TBD” as missing, not pending: SHRM’s guidance puts bonus and equity terms in the offer letter, and an invalid equity valuation can leave option holders owing immediate taxes plus a 20% penalty, per Carta’s 409A guidance (2026).
How do I check if a company is legitimate before accepting? Run the four free checks: Secretary of State registry lookup, email-domain match, recent review patterns, and a public search of the company name plus “scam.”
What does at-will employment mean for my acceptance? That either side can end the employment at any time for a lawful reason; it’s the default presumption in 49 states, with Montana requiring good cause after a probationary period.
When should I walk away instead of negotiating? When the offer asks for your money or personal data up front, refuses to put agreed pay in writing, or fails your verification checks; those are fraud and bad-faith patterns, not opening numbers.
Sources
- FTC: “New FTC Data Show Skyrocketing Consumer Reports About Game, Online Job Scams” (press release, Dec 12, 2024)
- FTC Consumer Advice: “Task scams create the illusion of making money” (Dec 12, 2024)
- FTC Consumer Advice: “Job Scams”
- BBB: “Employment scams 2026 update”
- BBB Marketplace Trust: 2025 Scam Tracker Risk Report overview
- Glassdoor: “6 Red Flags to Spot Before Taking the Job” (Sep 29, 2026)
- Delta Community Credit Union: “14 Warning Signs of Fake Job Scams” (Feb 18, 2026)
- SHRM: “14 Things Your Job Offer Letter Must Have To Be Effective” (Jun 6, 2017)
- US Department of Labor: FAQs, Final Rule: Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the FLSA
- US Department of Labor: Misclassification of Employees as Independent Contractors
- IRS: Topic No. 762, Independent Contractor vs. Employee (reviewed Sep 5, 2026)
- Carta: “What is a 409A valuation?” (published Aug 4, 2026)
- Cornell Law School Wex: “At-will employment” (reviewed May 2021)
- Rollins College Crummer Graduate School of Business: “Got a Verbal Job Offer but No Written Offer Yet? Do This Next”
Written by ResumeFlex. Questions or corrections? Contact ResumeFlex. Read our source and correction standards.
Filed under
Salary & Offers