On this page11 sections
Key takeaways
- Indeed Hiring Lab found the typical posted salary range spans about 17% from bottom to top (May 2023).
- 97% of NYC job postings analyzed in late 2023 topped out under double their minimum, so truly huge ranges are the exception (NYC Council Data Team).
- Washington State University research (Jan. 2024) found wide ranges make employers look less trustworthy; participants called one $100,000-wide band 'dishonest.'
- New Jersey's proposed rules (Sept. 2025) would cap a range's spread at 60% of its minimum; states are starting to police width.
- Citigroup briefly listed NYC jobs at $0–$2 million in Nov. 2022, the clearest public case of compliance gaming.
You open a posting and the salary range runs from $60,000 to $140,000. That’s not a range; that’s a zip code. Usually one of four things is going on: a law that forced a range onto the posting but never capped its width, a role that quietly covers several levels or several states, a genuinely wide pay grade, or negotiation hedging, and each cause leaves a fingerprint you can learn to read. Once you can, the range stops being noise and starts telling you what the employer will actually pay.
Pay transparency laws require a salary range, not a sensible one
Most posted ranges exist because the law says so, not because HR suddenly felt like sharing. Colorado started it on January 1, 2021, and about twenty US jurisdictions have followed. Nearly all of them demand a “good faith” range. Almost none of them say how wide that range can be.
A “good faith” salary range is one the employer honestly believes matches what it will pay for the job, and most laws demand one without ever defining how wide it can be.
The map, as of November 2026, comes from HR Dive’s pay transparency law tracker, last updated May 11, 2026:
- Colorado: effective Jan. 1, 2021, all employers. The range may span the lowest to the highest pay the employer “in good faith believes it might pay.”
- New York City: Nov. 1, 2022, employers with 4+ employees.
- California: Jan. 1, 2023, 15+ employees, under SB 1162.
- Washington: Jan. 1, 2023, 15+ employees. Ranges must run lowest to highest; open-ended postings like “$60,000 and up” don’t comply.
- New York State: Sept. 17, 2023, 4+ employees.
- Washington, D.C. (June 30, 2024; Maryland) Oct. 1, 2024.
- Illinois: Jan. 1, 2025, 15+ employees, with a benefits description required too.
- Minnesota: Jan. 1, 2025, 30+ employees; open-ended ranges are prohibited.
- New Jersey: June 1, 2025, 10+ employees; both ends of the range must be stated.
- Vermont (July 1, 2025 (5+ employees); Massachusetts) late July 2025 (25+ employees).
- Virginia (July 1, 2026; Connecticut) Oct. 1, 2026; Maine (estimated July 2026; Delaware) Sept. 26, 2027.
The laws explain why you suddenly see a salary range almost everywhere. By August 2023, half of all US postings on Indeed carried some pay information, up from 18% in February 2020, with Colorado leading at 81% (HR Dive, Sept. 19, 2023). But the laws don’t explain why your range spans $80,000.
Compliance gaming: a wide range is cheap insurance
Some employers post huge ranges because the law makes a range mandatory but leaves its width optional, and only a violation carries consequences. When New York City’s law took effect on Nov. 1, 2022, Citigroup listed several jobs at “$0 to $2 million”; a range the company blamed on a computer glitch, per CNBC’s account of the law’s rocky launch.
There’s also a mundane version that isn’t really gaming at all. A Gartner analyst told CNBC that a common practice is to set a budget target, then post a range roughly 20% above and below it. That’s actually informative, if you know the rule.
Why does a wide range work as a shield? Because if the eventual offer lands anywhere inside the band, the employer can claim compliance, and in Colorado, final pay can even fall outside the posted range as long as the estimate was made in good faith (HR Dive tracker). That’s the tell: a law meant to hand you information quietly gets repurposed to withhold it, though the data says gaming is the exception rather than the rule. Which brings us to the legitimate causes.
Four legitimate reasons a salary range runs wide
Not every wide range is a dodge. Four causes explain most of them, and each one leaves a different fingerprint.
| Cause | What it looks like | How honest is the signal | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compliance gaming | Huge span; the same range recycled across unrelated titles | Weak; the bottom is more truthful than the top | Ask for the budgeted band in the screen call |
| Multi-location remote pay | A “Remote (US” requisition; range stretches across markets | Moderate) the widest legitimate cause | Ask which geographic band applies to your location |
| One requisition, many levels | Posting covers several grades, e.g., Associate through Senior | Strong; real jobs at real levels | Ask which level the req is actually budgeted for |
| Genuine wide grade | Union grids, public-sector pay schedules | Strong; formal structure you can look up | Find the published step schedule; ask where you’d start |
The multi-location cause deserves a note. A single “Remote; US” posting can be filled by someone in a low-cost metro or in San Francisco. If the employer runs geographic pay bands, the honest range for the whole requisition is the widest one, the bottom set by the cheapest market, the top by the most expensive.
The multi-level cause is more common than people realize. If the requirements list mixes junior and senior expectations, you’re probably looking at one req that could be filled at several grades; our guide to must-have vs nice-to-have requirements in job ads can help you work out which bar you’d actually be measured against.
What the data says: most ranges are tighter than the headlines
Here’s the context most complaints skip. Indeed’s Hiring Lab found the typical gap between the low and high end of a posted US salary range is about 17%, based on postings analyzed in spring 2023 (Indeed Hiring Lab, May 18, 2023). The screaming ranges get the screenshots. The median posting doesn’t.
New York City’s own data team put harder numbers on it after analyzing more than 60,000 postings from Indeed and Google for Jobs in late 2023 (NYC Council Salary Transparency report). On Indeed, 85% of postings had a top-of-range less than 1.5 times the minimum, and 97% stayed under double. So here’s the number that settles the whole debate:
In all but 3% of the NYC job postings analyzed in late 2023, the top of the salary range was less than twice the minimum.
Where do wide ranges actually cluster? Three places, per the same research. Remote and high-wage roles lead; Indeed found spreads widening fastest there, with pharmacy up 56% and medical information up 49% in a year. Commission-heavy sales jobs came next, where the NYC Council found the widest median ratios (American Express topped out at 1.87 times its typical minimum). And early-law tech hubs: seven of the ten US metros with the biggest one-year jumps in range width were in California or Washington, with Seattle going from 14% to 21%.
Wide ranges can backfire on employers
Applicants notice, and research says they don’t like what they see. A Washington State University study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology ran three experiments comparing wide ranges (one spanned $58,100 to $152,500) against narrow ones of about $10,000. Wide ranges made employers seem significantly less trustworthy, participants privately described one as “dishonest,” “disingenuous,” and “ludicrous,” and doubted anyone would actually be paid the top (WSU, Jan. 3, 2024).
Cornell’s follow-up is newer and bigger. A team led by Alice Lee published four studies in the same journal on Feb. 16, 2026 (including an archival analysis of nearly 10 million US postings) and found women consistently preferred narrower ranges, with risk preference explaining much of the gap (Cornell Chronicle, Mar. 4, 2026). Participants who picked narrower ranges negotiated less assertively and were more satisfied with midpoint offers. When the researchers added plain context about typical starting salaries, the application and negotiation gaps disappeared.
The business case for tight ranges is getting hard to ignore. A 2024 Robert Half survey found 4 in 10 workers lose interest in listings that lack salary information, as HR Dive reported in March 2026. And a National Women’s Law Center/Morning Consult survey found about 1 in 3 workers had applied to a job they’d otherwise skip because the range was listed (CNBC, June 7, 2024).
A wide range can leave candidates unsure about the job’s level and likely pay. Ask which part of the range applies to the role you’re discussing.
What the top and the bottom of a salary range actually predict
The bottom of a posted range is the closest thing to a promise; the top is capacity, not commitment. Washington’s guidance is the clearest on this: the range must run from the lowest to the highest pay the employer has established before posting, but employers may legitimately post a narrower hiring range inside a bigger grade (Washington L&I). That means the top of a wide range may belong to a different level, a different city, or a different year.
Comp teams usually build the range around a budget. Remember the Gartner practice: the midpoint is the budget, with roughly 20% on each side (CNBC, 2022). The research lines up with what candidates already suspect; WSU’s participants doubted anyone got the top of a wide range, and Cornell’s participants were most satisfied with offers near the midpoint.
Ask the recruiter for the budgeted hiring range and the criteria for each level. Set your target using the scope of the role, your relevant experience, and comparable jobs; the posted maximum alone is not a reliable target. Base salary is also only one component; bonus and equity can move the real number a lot, so weigh any range against our guide to total compensation: base pay, bonuses, equity, benefits.
One more lever most people never use: in Illinois, if an employer hasn’t posted the pay scale, it must disclose it on request before any offer or compensation discussion (Illinois DOL). Asking costs you nothing.
How to narrow a wide range: a six-step script
You can usually shrink a wide range to a real number within two conversations. Ask in this order.
- Decode before you speak. Sort the range using the table above, gaming, geo, levels, or a genuine wide grade. Your questions change depending on which one it is.
- Open the screen call by asking for the budgeted band, not by giving your number. Try: “Before we go deeper, could you share the range budgeted for this role? I’d rather check we’re in the same universe than find out at the offer stage.”
- If they point back to the posted range, make it a factual question, not a negotiation. “Is that the actual budget for this req, or does it cover several levels or locations?” Recruiters answer that all day; it doesn’t mark you as difficult.
- Anchor from the median, not the bottom. “Based on the posted range, I’m targeting around the middle of the band for someone who checks most of the boxes; call it $X.” Since ranges are commonly built 20% above and below a budget, the middle is closer to the real number than either edge.
- Test whether the top is real. “What would put someone in the upper part of this range?” A concrete answer (specific skills, a level, a market) means the top exists for someone. A vague one means it doesn’t, for you.
- Get the number confirmed in writing, then verify against reality. A short recap email (“confirming the band we discussed”) turns a phone comment into a paper trail. And if the eventual offer lands below the posted minimum or far below what you discussed, respond with a plan rather than panic: our guide to responding to a low salary offer covers the exact moves.
Sometimes the range you see isn’t the employer’s
Two platform quirks muddle things further. LinkedIn has shown “estimated” ranges built from member-submitted pay data when employers provide none, a feature since Feb. 13, 2018, labeled separately from “Employer Provided” salaries (LinkedIn). And Google for Jobs aggregates scraped listings: the NYC Council found only 56% of postings on Google carried salary information versus 89% on Indeed, with gaps often caused by scraping, in one case, 300 of 374 hospital postings showed no salary on Indeed while the employer’s own site listed them (NYC Council).
If two platforms disagree, trust the employer’s own posting. Then treat even that as the opening bid of a conversation, not the final word.
States are starting to police range width
The loophole era is closing, slowly. New Jersey’s proposed regulations, released Sept. 15, 2025, would bar any range whose top-to-bottom spread exceeds 60% of its minimum, though the rules are still not final as of November 2026 (Porzio Bromberg & Newman, Sept. 30, 2025; NJ Department of Labor). California’s SB 642, signed Oct. 8, 2025, tightens its definition to what the employer “reasonably expects to pay upon hire,” and Minnesota already bans open-ended ranges (HR Dive tracker).
Ask about the budgeted range early, even when a posting meets local disclosure requirements. If the answer stays vague, you can decide how much more time to invest.
Salary range FAQs
Are wide salary ranges legal? Yes, in most US jurisdictions. Pay transparency laws require a good-faith range but set no width limit, so a huge span is usually legal even when it’s unhelpful, though New Jersey’s proposed 60% cap would change that if adopted.
Will I get paid the top of the salary range? Rarely. The top usually belongs to a different level, a different location, or an exceptional candidate, and WSU’s research found applicants assume exactly that, which is why wide ranges undermine trust.
What does the midpoint of a salary range mean? It usually approximates the budget for a fully qualified hire. A common practice, per a Gartner analyst, is posting a range about 20% above and below the budgeted target.
Which states require salary ranges in job postings as of November 2026? Colorado, California, New York (state and NYC), Washington, Hawaii, Washington, D.C., Maryland, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, Vermont, Massachusetts, Virginia, Connecticut and Maine are in effect, with Delaware following in September 2027, per HR Dive’s tracker.
Why do remote jobs have the widest salary ranges? Because one remote requisition can hire in many pay markets at once. If the employer uses geographic pay bands, the honest range spans the cheapest market to the most expensive, and Indeed found ranges widening fastest for remote, high-wage roles.
Should I apply to a job with a huge salary range? Yes, if the role otherwise fits. A wide range isn’t automatically low pay, decode the cause with the table above, then use the screen-call script to find the budgeted band before you invest much time.
Why do some job postings list a $1 salary range? That’s compliance gaming: a technically valid, information-free range. Good-faith standards and proposed spread caps exist precisely to close that loophole.
How do I ask a recruiter for the real salary budget? Ask for the “budgeted band” framed as mutual time-saving: “Could you share the range budgeted for this role so we don’t waste each other’s time?” Then anchor from its median, not its bottom.
Sources
- HR Dive: A running list of states and localities that require employers to post pay ranges (tracker, last updated May 11, 2026)
- Indeed Hiring Lab: Advertised US Salary Ranges Are Widening in Some Areas (May 18, 2023)
- Cornell Chronicle: Job listings with wide pay ranges may deter female applicants (Mar. 4, 2026)
- Washington State University: Job ads with wide pay ranges can deter applicants (Jan. 3, 2024)
- HR Dive: How wide pay ranges may deter women from applying (Mar. 5, 2026)
- New York City Council Data Team: Salary Transparency report (postings analyzed Oct.–Nov. 2023)
- New Jersey Department of Labor: Pay and Benefits Transparency Law
- Porzio Bromberg & Newman: NJDOL’s proposed pay transparency regulations (Sept. 30, 2025)
- Washington State L&I: Equal Pay & Opportunities Act
- Illinois Department of Labor: Equal Pay Act Salary Transparency
- CNBC Make It: $2 million ranges, deleted job posts: NYC’s salary transparency law is off to a rocky start (Nov. 3, 2022)
- CNBC Make It: More states are passing pay transparency laws (June 7, 2024)
- HR Dive: Indeed says half of its US job postings now feature pay information (Sept. 19, 2023)
- LinkedIn: Introducing Salary Insights on Jobs (Feb. 13, 2018)
Written by ResumeFlex. Questions or corrections? Contact ResumeFlex. Read our source and correction standards.
Filed under
Salary & Offers